Miers' withdrawal a rarity, political scientist says

Friday, October 28, 2005

Harriet Miers' withdrawal on Thursday, Oct. 27, of her nomination to the Supreme Court is a "rare case of withdrawal for purely political reasons," according to a University of North Texas political scientist.

Dr. Corey Ditslear, associate professor of political science, says that in her letter to President Bush requesting her withdrawal, Miers claimed to be concerned about document requests from the White House Counsel's Office that raise separation of powers issues, "but all requests thus far have acknowledged the need for executive privilege and have sought only to learn the types of issues she was charged with investigating, not the content of the advice."

"The real reason for appears to be an attempt to save the president continued political embarrassment when his polling numbers are down," Ditslear says. "A Senate meeting last night convinced those involved that Miers was in for a very tough fight and a possible rejection."

He points out that 10 others have previously withdrawn their nominations to the Supreme Court -- usually for health issues or a scandal.

He adds that if Bush can nominate a replacement for Miers sometime next week -- "something that may be difficult as the expectation that he consult with key Senate Republicans has been heightened" -- the Senate would be unable to schedule confirmation hearings for the nominee until mid-December or even early January.

With the Supreme Court almost four weeks into this year's term, Associate Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, whom Miers was to replace, will stay on the Court longer than expected. O'Connor, Distlear says, "once again becomes a swing vote on a number of key cases currently before the Court."

"She has heard oral arguments and will now be given the opportunity to vote on cases involving parental consent for abortion and state control of euthanasia, as well as many other issues. The Court dynamic has unexpectedly changed for the next two to three months," he says. "Miers' withdrawal saves the president potential embarrassment, but likely extends Justice O'Connor's influence into 2006."

Ditslear teaches courses on judicial politics, international law and human rights, Supreme Court decision making, women and politics and constitutional law focusing on civil rights and civil liberties and government powers. He was a legal intern for the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee, Anti-Trust Subcommittee, in the summer of 1994, preparing the committee's statements and questions on then-Supreme Court nominee Stephen Breyer and witnessing the confirmation hearings. He has published research on the Supreme Court in Vanderbilt Law Review, Journal of Politics, and Law and Society Review. His full biographical information is available at www.psci.unt.edu/Ditslear/cvuntmaster.pdf.

UNT News Service Phone Number: (940) 565-2108


Latest News

Mariachi sheet music
Wednesday, July 9, 2014

The internationally-renowned Mariachi Sol de Mexico — a Grammy-nominated ensemble —  will be the headline performer of the University of North Texas Mariachi Aguilitas Summer Camp, an annual week-long workshop that teaches musical skills to middle school and high school mariachi players.

Clifford Morrison
Wednesday, July 9, 2014

University of North Texas senior Clifford Morrison, of Hughes Springs, has received a $5,000 Phi Kappa Phi Fellowship for his first year of graduate school. Morrison is one of eight students from Texas colleges and universities to win a fellowship this year.

Eli Saslow
Wednesday, July 9, 2014

For the second year in a row, an article in The Washington Post by reporter Eli Saslow received the first place award in the Best American Newspaper Narrative Writing Contest sponsored by the University of North Texas’ Mayborn Literary Nonfiction Conference.

Individual fibers for C-lignin-based carbon fiber
Monday, July 7, 2014

Researchers at the University of North Texas have created a new carbon fiber from plants that can replace common petroleum and coal-based products in wide range of goods including parts for cars, aircraft, electronics and sports equipment. The patent-pending carbon fiber also is stronger and lighter than similar products on the market. 

Thursday, July 3, 2014

Nationally known leaders in autism research will discuss the latest developments related to autism treatment at the 6th Annual Adventures in Autism Intervention and Research Conference, presented by the UNT Kristin Farmer Autism Center.